Both can make you a working key. The difference is mostly about convenience, timing and the type of vehicle, so here is a straight comparison.

DealershipMobile locksmith
Where it happensAt the dealer service department, so the car has to be there, sometimes by towAt your car, wherever it is
HoursBusiness hours and appointmentsLocksmith Knights answers 24 hours a day
TimingA key may need to be orderedOften handled in one visit
Vehicle coverageEvery model they sellMost makes and models
PriceVaries by vehicle for both. Ask each for a total.

When the dealer may be the better choice

  • Your vehicle is a very new model whose security system is not yet supported by independent tools.
  • Your warranty or service plan covers key replacement.
  • The car is already at the dealership for other work.

When a locksmith makes more sense

  • You lost every key away from home or after hours.
  • The car is at your home, work or a parking deck and you would rather not tow it.
  • You need it the same day.

Questions to ask either one

  • What is the total price, including cutting, programming and any trip charge?
  • Does it include a tested working remote?
  • Will the lost keys be erased from the car?
  • How long will it take, and is there a warranty on the key?

Want a quote for your car key in Raleigh? We are mobile and answer 24 hours a day.

Call (919) 397-5583Areas we serve

Questions we hear

Which one is cheaper?

It depends on the vehicle. Get a total price from both, including cutting, programming and any trip charge, and compare like for like.

Is a locksmith key as good as a dealer key?

A properly programmed key from a quality supplier works the same in daily use. Ask what brand the key or fob is and whether it comes with a warranty.

Can I buy a key online and have it programmed?

Sometimes. Ask before you buy, because the wrong chip or frequency is a common problem with online keys.

Related

Car Key ReplacementLost Car KeysKey Fob & Remote ProgrammingTransponder Key ProgrammingLost All Your Car KeysCar Key and Key Fob Programming

We travel to Raleigh, Cary, Apex, Garner, Wake Forest, Knightdale, Morrisville, Holly Springs and the rest of the Triangle. Browse more locksmith guides.